Stony Brook Medicine Health News
A tween girl sitting on her couch, looking directly at her smartphone.

Is Your Child Too Young for a Smartphone? New Study Reveals Risks

Many parents wonder about the right time to give their child a smartphone. While these devices can help us stay connected, there are growing concerns about how they affect young, developing minds. According to Common Sense Media, 42 percent of kids have a phone by age 10, 71 percent by age 12, and 91 percent by age 14. A new study shines a light on the potential health risks of giving a smartphone to a child too early.

Families today face many challenges in our digital world. Understanding the facts can help you make the best choice for your child’s well-being. This article will break down the latest research and offer simple, practical steps to create a healthy digital plan for your family.

What a New Study Reveals

A recent study published in the journal Pediatrics looked at the connection between smartphone ownership and health in early adolescents. Researchers studied over 10,000 kids to see how having a phone at a young age impacted them. The findings are important for every parent to consider.

Key Findings on Smartphones and Tween Health

The study followed children around the age of 12. It compared those who owned a smartphone to those who did not. The results showed a clear link between owning a smartphone and several health issues.

Here’s a simple breakdown of what the researchers found:

  • Higher Risk of Depression: Tweens aged 12 who owned a smartphone had a 31 percent higher risk of depression compared to their peers without a phone.

  • Increased Chance of Obesity: Smartphone ownership at age 12 was linked to a 40 percent higher chance of having obesity.

  • More Sleep Problems: Children with smartphones were 62 percent more likely to get insufficient sleep. Sleep is crucial for a child’s physical and mental development, and a lack of sleep can lead to several problems in tweens and teens.

The study found that the younger a child was when they got a phone, the higher their risk was for obesity and poor sleep.

Even more telling, the researchers followed up with kids who didn’t have a phone at age 12. Among this group, those who got a smartphone by age 13 had greater odds of developing clinical-level mental health issues and sleep problems within that year.

The conclusion is clear: smartphone ownership at a young age is associated with significant risks to a child’s mental and physical health. This information isn’t meant to scare you, but to empower you with knowledge.

Creating a Healthy Family Digital Plan

Seeing this data might make you wonder — “What’s the alternative?” The good news is that you can delay giving your child a smartphone while still keeping them safe and connected. The key is to create a family digital plan that sets healthy boundaries.

Why Waiting Is a Healthy Choice

Delaying smartphone ownership can give your child a stronger foundation for their teen years. By waiting, you help protect them from the risks of depression, obesity and poor sleep highlighted in the study.

It also gives them more time to develop important life skills. This includes learning how to interact face-to-face, manage boredom without a screen and build hobbies that don’t involve a phone. Waiting until they are older and more mature can help them handle the pressures of social media and constant connectivity.

Practical Tips for Your Family Plan

Building a plan that doesn’t revolve around a personal smartphone is easier than you might think. Here are some practical steps you can take today.

1. Use Shared Family Devices

Instead of a personal phone, consider having a shared family tablet or computer. Keep it in a central location, like the living room. This allows you to supervise your child’s screen time and ensure they are accessing age-appropriate content.

2. Set Clear Screen Time Limits

Work with your child to establish firm rules for screen time. This could be a daily limit of one hour on weekdays and 1-2 hours on weekends for recreational use. Using a timer can be helpful. When the time is up, the device gets put away. Consistency is the most important part of making this work.

3. Engage in Conversations About Device Usage

Caregivers should take the time to understand their children’s device habits by asking questions and discussing their online activities. This not only helps build trust but also allows parents to guide their children in making healthier digital choices.

3. Encourage Non-Digital Activities

Help your child discover the joy of offline activities. This could be anything from joining a sports team to learning a musical instrument or just spending time outside. The more engaged they are in the real world, the less they will feel the need for a screen.

4. Model Healthy Digital Habits

Children learn by watching their parents. Be mindful of your own smartphone use. Put your phone away during meals and conversations. Show them that it’s important to be present with the people you are with. Your actions will speak louder than your words.

5. Create Tech-Free Zones and Times

Designate certain areas of your home as tech-free. Bedrooms are a great place to start, as this helps protect sleep. You can also set tech-free times, such as before school, during family dinners or one hour before bedtime. This creates space for connection, establishes a healthy routine and reduces dependency on devices.

What About Staying in Touch?

One of the biggest reasons parents give a child a smartphone is for communication. Fortunately, there are great alternatives that don’t come with the risks of an internet-connected device.

Consider a basic phone that only allows calls and texts, such as the Gabb phone. These “dumb phones” let your child reach you in an emergency or coordinate pickups without giving them access to social media and the entire internet.

Some smartwatches designed for kids also offer limited calling features, providing another safe option.

Your Child’s Well-Being Comes First

Deciding when to give your child a smartphone is a personal choice. However, the evidence shows that waiting can have powerful benefits for their mental and physical health. By delaying smartphone ownership and creating a thoughtful family digital plan, you give your child the space to grow, learn and thrive without the pressures of a device designed for adults.

You are in the best position to guide your child through today’s world. Armed with this knowledge, you can make choices that support their long-term happiness and health.

  • Anthony J Anzalone, PsyD
    Psychology

    Dr. Anthony Anzalone is a licensed clinical psychologist and clinical assistant professor in the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Health at Stony Brook School of Medicine. He obtained his PsyD at Long Island University, C.W. Post Campus. He brings over two decades of clinical experience to Stony Brook, starting off his career working at a residential facility for five years helping children with various behavioral and emotional disorders. Following this, he worked in private practice, where he formed a partnership with colleges that specialized in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy for individuals with anxiety disorders.

    View all posts
This article is intended to be general and/or educational in nature. Always consult your healthcare professional for help, diagnosis, guidance and treatment.